Protest Pizza + Bar, a lowly basement slice joint, is an anomaly in the outrageously upscale DMV pizza scene. Even the neighborhood’s famous Trio Restaurant, with its notoriously gooey, greasy pizza, went upscale with a brick oven before its demise1. However, the queer-owned Protest Pizza fits like a glove in the Dupont Circle 17th Street strip, long the epicenter of DC’s gay nightlife. Protest Pizza’s clever logo — a fist gripping a pizza cutter — neatly conveys its homage to the neighborhood’s historical fight for gay rights.


Photos from Leigh Mosley’s Pioneers for Justice: Black Lesbians in the DMV adorn the walls. With friendly employees, a welcoming vibe, killer neon signage, and a cute little bar-what’s not to like?




A dedicated slice joint, Protest Pizza gets DishingPizza‘s respect. Furthermore, the slice selection is terrific. DishingPizza went for a Classic cheese slice and a Green Line slice – pesto base, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, spinach, and crumbled feta.

Before reheating, the large slices looked sad, like old dogs continually passed over for puppies at the shelter. Unfortunately, a few minutes in the hot oven did little to perk up the slices. Yes, they were hot, but they still tasted old.2 The mozzarella, especially on the cheese slice, extruded too much oil and not enough quality. The crust was perfectly decent New York-style but lacked any tangy pizzazz.
It’s possible that these slices had, indeed, been sitting around too long and should have been discarded. However, a joint that traffics in slices should do better.
Two pizza places less than a block apart are worlds apart: One precious and pricey (Gemini), the other unpretentious and workmanlike (Protest Pizza). Frankensteining the two, and taking a few bits and pieces from other local Dupont Circle pizzerias, might result in something spectacular.
Protest Pizza + Bar
1633½ P Street NW, Washington, DC 20036
Style: New York
Pizza quality: 🍕🍕
Overall experience: ⭐⭐⭐
Slice: $5.00
Slice price per square Inch: $0.15
Slice greed factor: 🤑
Pie (16″ round): $25.00
Pie price per square inch: $0.12
